Domain News

Stay up-to-date on domain industry news and trends

Domain News

2012-03-13| The Brief Case - March 2012 Google Loses WIPO Arbitration over YouTube.com.pe by Chase Marshall :: Sedo.com Legal Staff

On February 20, 2012, the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) Arbitration and Mediation Center handed Google Inc. a quick and decisive defeat in a domain name dispute they filed. The domain in dispute? Youtube.com.pe, registered in Peru (.pe, including all second-level extensions, is the Country Code Top Level Domain [ccTLD] for the South American nation).

As many know, Google owns and operates the YouTube website and its home domain, youtube.com, which was registered on February 14, 2005. Google also holds multiple trademark registrations for the term “YouTube,” the first of which was filed with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office on January 30, 2006. Google has also held a registered trademark for the term in Peru since May 7, 2007.

The domain name at the center of this dispute, youtube.com.pe, was registered in Peru on May 29, 2006. In addition to the registration of this domain name, Google claimed that the website on youtube.com.pe provided links to competitors of their YouTube service. These two factors were the basis of Google’s claim that youtube.com.pe was using the domain name in bad faith by intentionally causing confusion among consumers. Under the Peruvian policy regarding domain name disputes, Google had to prove that:

1) the domain name was identical or similar to the point of creating confusion with respect to: trademarks in Peru; names of individuals; names of official Peruvian government bodies, etc.,
2) the applicant for the domain name had no rights or legitimate interests in the domain name, and
3) the domain name was registered and used in bad faith.

Normally this would seem like an easy decision in favor of Google. Google has a registered trademark in Peru and the domain name at issue is virtually identical to that trademark. Also; the registrant did and does not appear to have any legitimate interest in the domain name; these circumstances lend to a finding that the domain was used in bad faith.

The arbitration panel based its final decision on a strict reading of the Peruvian policy concerning domain name disputes. Unfortunately for Google, Peru has extremely strict trademark law. The law states that the right to sole use of a trademark shall be acquired by registration of the goods to the competent national office. Essentially, Google did not have the exclusive right to use the “YouTube” mark in Peru until it registered the mark with the Peruvian government. And although one does not have to be a Peruvian citizen to register a .pe domain name, one does need a validly registered Peruvian trademark in order to challenge a .pe domain name.

Ultimately, the decision in this arbitration boiled down to the specific dates involved. Because Google didn’t register the “YouTube” trademark in Peru until after the youtube.com.pe domain was registered, Google does not have the right to prevent the use of that domain name. Google lost the arbitration because of the first tenet of the Peruvian domain name dispute policy—at the time that the owner of youtube.com.pe registered the domain, it was not identical or similar to any preexisting Peruvian trademarks.

This decision makes clear that the specific county in which a domain name is registered can make a significant difference when the legitimate use of that domain is challenged. Before registering a domain name, it is extremely important to understand the dispute policy that will be applied should any complaint arise. Differences in trademark law between countries can also play an important role in domain name disputes, so any registrant or buyer should explore those differences in an effort to make smarter investment decisions with reduced or no risk.

2014-07-25| World Domain Day - New International Conference In India! Expanding the Global Domain Market to India
2014-07-14| Sedo reveals International gTLD Awareness Report Only 40% are aware of the new TLDs being introduced
2014-07-14| Virtual Domain conference -July 24, 2014 A new step towards the future
2014-07-14| ICANN Faces Scrutiny from Within Independent accountability mechanism
2014-06-10| The Future of Internet Governance ICA Maintains Its Vigilance
2014-04-17| Data Security at Sedo We're answering most frequently asked questions
2014-04-16| Tucows Now Live on SedoMLS Network SedoMLS Network Now Bringing 17 Million Premium Domains to Third Largest Registrar’s Leading Reseller Channel
2014-04-11| ICANN Orders Bulk Transfer ICANN Orders Bulk Transfer of Domain Names from De-Accredited Registrars
2014-02-24| Sedo and Web.com Announce Partnership Leading Registrar Joins SedoMLS Network, Giving Customers Direct Access to 18 Million Premium Domains
2014-02-20| Sedo and .CLUB Amp Up Domain Competition with Auction Snowboarding.club, Skiing.club Among Names Available in Special Auction for Pre-Registration Priority on February 19
2014-02-13| Federal Appeals Court Rejects Contributory Liability Claims Federal Appeals Court in California Rejects Contributory Liability Claims Under Anticybersquatting Act
2014-02-13| The Top Five Mistakes in Parking Learn how to select the correct account settings and avoid the top five mistakes in parking
2014-02-12| Save the Date to Bid on .Asia Premium Names ok.asia, 80.asia, u.asia and many more
2014-01-31| German Registrar Checkdomain Joins SedoMLS First to Use New Partner Listing Process
2014-01-24| Sedo now offers Alipay New Online Payment Method
2014-01-24| 22.cn Joins SedoMLS Continuing the Network’s Expansion in China
2013-12-19| ICANN Explains Its Position on Uniform Contracts Anyone registering a domain name through an ICANN-accredited registrar is required to accept provisions in the registration agreement
2013-12-18| SedoMLS Network Welcomes Hosting.kr as its Newest Partner Sedo is happy to announce that Hosting.kr, the registrar brand of MegaZone, has joined the SedoMLS Premium network.
2013-11-15| Chinese Registrar Bizcn.com Joins SedoMLS Sell your domains worldwide
2013-11-13| Yahoo Opens Up Treasure Chest of Domains in Sedo Auction More Than 100 Premium Domain Names from Yahoo Portfolio to be Auctioned on World’s Largest Domain Marketplace from November 14th - 21st
2013-10-02| ICA Urges ICANN to Clean Up TM Rules for New TLDs Read what the ICA thinks about the Rights Protection Mechanism (RPM)
2013-08-30| Sedo Launches Portuguese-language Website Domain Name Transactions and Services Targeting Customers in Brazil
2013-08-29| Belgian Registrar bNamed.net Joins the SedoMLS More exposure for your Sedo domain listings with a new distribution partner
2013-08-28| ICANN Explores Viability of Dotless Domains Will new gTLDs create Name Collisions on the Web?
2013-08-26| Parking: New Layout Selection We have replaced some older parking layouts with newer layouts with stronger performance

Search our News

Please enter your Keyword

Stay in the Know

Get what you need:

  • Industry news & Trends
  • Sedo auction & event updates
  • Free Guide to Domain Attraction

Opt-out or edit subscriptions at any time. Please review Sedo's Privacy Policy to see how we protect your personal information.

Privacy Policy.