Domain News

Stay up-to-date on domain industry news and trends

Domain News

Feb/15/12| The Brief Case - February 2012 Arbitration Panel Applies the New CDRP and Orders Domain Name Transfer by Chase Marshall :: Legal Staff, Sedo.com

The Canadian Internet Registration Authority (CIRA), the sole registry for .CA country code Top Level Domains (ccTLDs), recently released a new version of its Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (CDRP), effective August 22, 2011. Changes to the CDRP were aimed at making the Policy more consistent with the broader Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP). One of the most notable changes is the expansion of factors for legitimate interest and bad-faith registration.

These changes were first employed in a dispute between Glen Raven, Inc. (the Complainant) and Tomislav Kotarac (the Registrant) over the domain name sunbrella.ca. Glen Raven, a maker of woven fabrics for a variety of uses, obtained in 1972 a Canadian trademark registration for the term “Sunbrella.” Glen Raven’s principal website for their Sunbrella fabric line is at sunbrella.com; the company also owns sunbrella.net, sunbrella.org, and sunbrella.info, all of which previously redirected users to sunbrella.com (they now redirect visitors to glenraven.com, Glen Raven’s corporate website).

On June 6, 2011, Tomislav Kotarac registered sunbrella.ca. In his Response to Glen Raven’s Complaint, and in defense of his registration, Kotarac stated that he “registered [sunbrella.ca] upon conceiving an idea as a brand name for a new consumer product.” He argued that he “is an entrepreneur with significant experience in the consumer package goods industry.” Kotarac also claimed that he planned to register the mark “Sunbrella” in association with his “new consumer product,” but no registration had been filed. However, he didn’t indicate why he chose the term “Sunbrella” or what type of product he planned to develop.

Under the CDRP, like the more well-known UDRP, Glen Raven had to prove three elements in order to prevail on its Complaint:

1. The Registrant’s .CA domain name is confusingly similar to a mark to which the Complainant had rights prior to the date of registration, and the Complainant continued to have those rights;
2. The Registrant had no legitimate interest in the domain name; and
3. The Registrant registered the domain name in bad faith.

For the first element, the arbitration panel easily decided that sunbrella.ca was identical, and therefore confusingly similar, to Glen Raven’s “Sunbrella” trademark.

As for the second element, the CDRP provides six circumstances, any of which, if proved, would demonstrate that Kotarac had a legitimate interest in the domain name. Boiled down, these grounds of legitimate interest are that use of the domain by the registrant is either (1) in good faith or (2) non-commercial or that the domain name is (3) a clearly descriptive phrase, (4) a generic term, (5) an individual’s name, or (6) a geographical name. Additionally, the new version of the CDRP allowed the arbitration panel to look beyond these six circumstances to find legitimate use.

However, after reviewing all evidence, the panel concluded that Kotarac did not have a legitimate interest in sunbrella.ca. Kotarac seems to have been handicapped by the lack of evidence he provided, only indicating that he planned to develop a product and market it under the name “Sunbrella.” This was not enough to persuade the panel.

Having determined that sunbrella.ca is confusingly similar to the mark “Sunbrella,” and that Kotarac had no legitimate interest in the domain name, the panel moved to the third factor: proof of bad faith. Under the previous CDRP, arbitration panels were limited to only three factors when finding bad faith: (1) the Registrant acquired the domain name primarily to profit from its sale to the Complainant or a competitor; (2) the Registrant engaged in a pattern of registering other domain names that were marks; or (3) the Registrant acquired the domain name primarily to disrupt the Complainant’s business. If the Registrant’s behavior did not fit one of these three scenarios, registration was not in bad faith.

The revised CDRP, however, includes a new fourth factor, which states that there is a showing of bad faith if “the registrant has intentionally attempted to attract, for commercial gain, internet users to the registrant’s website or other online location, by creating a likelihood of confusion with the complainant’s mark.” Additionally, a panel is free to find bad faith outside of these four factors if evidence supports it.

In this case, the panel found that Kotarac did register the domain name in bad faith under the fourth factor; he intended to develop a new consumer product, which the panel inferred was for commercial gain. This commercial gain, in combination with the likelihood of confusion caused by sunbrella.ca, was enough to satisfy the fourth bad faith factor. In the end, Kotarac was ordered to transfer the domain to Glen Raven.

The expansion of the legitimate interest and bad faith factors of the CDRP further aligns it to the more widely-used UDRP. Though some of the specific language remains different, the analysis of domain name disputes under the CDRP is now more similar to analyses under the UDRP. This similarity provides for a more uniform resolution of domain name disputes across international boundaries and across more ccTLDs.

Apr/17/14| Data Security at Sedo We're answering most frequently asked questions
Apr/16/14| Tucows Now Live on SedoMLS Network SedoMLS Network Now Bringing 17 Million Premium Domains to Third Largest Registrar’s Leading Reseller Channel
Apr/11/14| ICANN Orders Bulk Transfer ICANN Orders Bulk Transfer of Domain Names from De-Accredited Registrars
Feb/24/14| Sedo and Web.com Announce Partnership Leading Registrar Joins SedoMLS Network, Giving Customers Direct Access to 18 Million Premium Domains
Feb/20/14| Sedo and .CLUB Amp Up Domain Competition with Auction Snowboarding.club, Skiing.club Among Names Available in Special Auction for Pre-Registration Priority on February 19
Feb/13/14| Federal Appeals Court Rejects Contributory Liability Claims Federal Appeals Court in California Rejects Contributory Liability Claims Under Anticybersquatting Act
Feb/13/14| The Top Five Mistakes in Parking Learn how to select the correct account settings and avoid the top five mistakes in parking
Feb/12/14| Save the Date to Bid on .Asia Premium Names ok.asia, 80.asia, u.asia and many more
Jan/31/14| German Registrar Checkdomain Joins SedoMLS First to Use New Partner Listing Process
Jan/24/14| Sedo now offers Alipay New Online Payment Method
Jan/24/14| 22.cn Joins SedoMLS Continuing the Network’s Expansion in China
Dec/19/13| ICANN Explains Its Position on Uniform Contracts Anyone registering a domain name through an ICANN-accredited registrar is required to accept provisions in the registration agreement
Dec/18/13| SedoMLS Network Welcomes Hosting.kr as its Newest Partner Sedo is happy to announce that Hosting.kr, the registrar brand of MegaZone, has joined the SedoMLS Premium network.
Nov/15/13| Chinese Registrar Bizcn.com Joins SedoMLS Sell your domains worldwide
Nov/13/13| Yahoo Opens Up Treasure Chest of Domains in Sedo Auction More Than 100 Premium Domain Names from Yahoo Portfolio to be Auctioned on World’s Largest Domain Marketplace from November 14th - 21st
Oct/02/13| ICA Urges ICANN to Clean Up TM Rules for New TLDs Read what the ICA thinks about the Rights Protection Mechanism (RPM)
Aug/30/13| Sedo Launches Portuguese-language Website Domain Name Transactions and Services Targeting Customers in Brazil
Aug/29/13| Belgian Registrar bNamed.net Joins the SedoMLS More exposure for your Sedo domain listings with a new distribution partner
Aug/28/13| ICANN Explores Viability of Dotless Domains Will new gTLDs create Name Collisions on the Web?
Aug/26/13| Parking: New Layout Selection We have replaced some older parking layouts with newer layouts with stronger performance
Aug/22/13| OnlineNIC joins the SedoMLS Premium network US-based registrar brings Sedo users’ domains to more potential buyers
Jul/29/13| Sedo Sponsors the Digital Marketing & gTLD Strategy Congress Sedo will be sponsoring the Digital Marketing & gTLD Strategy Congress taking place September 26-27 at the Park Plaza London.
Jul/29/13| WIPO: No Transfer of Domains in Mexican Contact Lenses Case WIPO decided two domain name disputes involving the sale of contact lenses in Mexico.
Jul/29/13| Lime Crush Mobile boosts revenue through mobile traffic New parking template increases RPM of mobile traffic on parked pages around 20%
Jul/16/13| Sell Your .EU Domains via the SedoMLS Premium Network Sedo and EURid partner to bring the .EU extension into the world’s largest domain distribution network

Search our News

Please enter your Keyword

Stay in the Know

Get what you need:

  • Industry news & Trends
  • Sedo auction & event updates
  • Free Guide to Domain Attraction

Opt-out or edit subscriptions at any time. Please review Sedo's Privacy Policy to see how we protect your personal information.

Privacy Policy.